Friday, November 4, 2016

Teacher Engagement postives and negatives

In my observations I was able to view two teachers. This gave me  different perspectives on how each instructors approach the students differently, and how they set up the students for success. In this blog I want to discuss the positive and negative actions the instructors made. I will also explain the differences between each instructor and how it influenced the students and classroom environments.

Attitudes:
Instructor 1:
This instructor really captured my attention from the moment I walked into the class. Immediately she welcomed me in by asking the students to say hello and acknowledge my presence. From this I could tell that she wanted to make sure everyone felt comfortable with me and I with them. Then the students got right back to work, quietly, and respectfully. Throughout the hours I spent there, I noticed her attitude always stayed kind and firm. She made sure that the students knew that she was not the only person they could go to if they had any questions. She pointed out that I was there to help but also to make sure to ask their peers of any doubts or confusion they may have. This instructor really pushed for interactions and not to be afraid to work together. The next month that I came in, she had the students in different seats, but I noticed something so amazing. The students rarely got up to ask her questions, students themselves were teaching each other and walking around asking if any one needed help. The students finished their assignments at a faster pace and had their work was done very well.
At times students still had to ask her questions, and her approach was so sincere and understanding. She would answer their questions by asking the class to listen so in case they had that question too. She never made the students feel secluded, she always got the class involved.
Instructor 2:
This instructor was a good teacher but she made me and her students feel detached from her. When I walked in she was kind but it was a little awkward. I did not get introduced so I walked around the class introducing myself. The students became really unfocused because they did not know who I was and started talking among themselves to figure out why I was there. She did not review if they had finished their assignments and began placing them in groups to study words that they were learning. This strategy was affective to some students because they could pronounce the words correctly and understand the meaning. But there were others who felt uncomfortable and began to goof off because they did not know what was going on. I, myself was placed with students who were beginners and could understand what I was saying but had a limit of speaking back to me. My group had a task of memorizing 100 vocabulary words by repeating them with me and then writing them down. These students did not get the chance to take part in the stations. So they became frustrated, and lose concentration because they kept asking when they would be able to participate. I felt that the instructors attitude towards these students had lack of consideration and involvement. she tended to isolate the students who needed extra help and it caused them to keep falling behind the other students. Although she was kind, she lacked the connection between her and her students and having the students feel on the same level or as capable as others.
Strategies:
Both instructors used similar strategies in their classrooms. They both liked the idea of setting up the students in groups to work together in class. Although each instructor varied in keeping a controlled environment. For example one classroom keep with the flow of knowing what they needed to do next, and they had had past She always uses visuals, examples, and gives room for questioning so that they students are not afraid to have a complete understanding.
The students have experience of doing these assignments because the instructor uses a routine to get them situated. As for the other classroom, it seemed as if the students were lost, very routey and did not listen very well. The instructor asked them to do a classroom assignment and she wrote it on the board on what they needed to do. So some of the students could read what she wrote, but many ELLs could not comprehend it. This caused students to become restless and talkative because they did not know what to do. The classroom because loud and the instructor became overwhelmed by all the commotion. Because of this bad start, it continued on throughout the day, it seemed that they students were all given the same expectation without any consideration if they needed the extra help or interpretation. The majority of the time only written an vocal strategies were used in this classroom.
Knowledge:
Instructor 1:
The students never looked disappointed or bored. They were always eager to finish their assignments and jump to the next one. I walked around the class and I could hear them talk to the other students about what they had just learned or share the creation they had just made. They instructor told me she has had 15 years of experience and I feel like that really shows through her students. They were exposed to all sorts of different materials to do a task with quality work and really get a good understanding. This shows that the instructor is well aware that students need these exposers because the more options they have the more they are willing to do something. Why? well this is because they are given the opportunity to pick and choose for themselves. She also incorporates connecting their cultural backgrounds to the assignments they do, such as when they are doing their readings, she asks them to write down any past experiences or prior knowledge to what they have read.
Instructor 2:
The students in this classroom tend to figit a lot in their seats, draw on their paper, talk to their peers and slack off. I see that the instructor bases the tasks more off of making sure she hits all the points that she needs to. Like following a textbook. The words and definitions are all there but they variety to learn them is lacking. They students seem to  stay quiet when she asks a question and they take a longer time to get through a responsibity becuase they do not know how to start and where to start. I could tell that the instructors knowledge was very well, she knew her matter. But the teaching portion was not very affective and it was sad to see the students staring at a blank piece of paper, hoping time would fly by for reassess. She did not use a lot of the strategies that I learned in my class. Like braking it down instructions, giving them the ability to connect their cultural background, giving them the control and independence, and having that bond with them to set a safe environment.
Reflect:
It amazes me that there is so much more to being a teacher then many of us have thought. It is not just about just being able to know the contect well and repeat it to the students like a textbook. It is about having the students feel connected and making it enjoyable. Each day has long hours and they are stuffed with all sorts of information. But many times it will go through one ear and out the other. But by giving them unique tools and strategies, the material becomes easier to understand. The references become easier to remember, they feel proud of their work and want to help other students, and they get a sense of confidence.

No comments:

Post a Comment